Key Texas abortion opponent sees Supreme Court decision as validation to keep fighting

Sign up for The Brief, our regular newsletter that keeps readers up to velocity connected the astir indispensable Texas news.

ABILENE — Mark Lee Dickson bounded connected signifier astatine FountainGate Fellowship successful this West Texas municipality Sunday arsenic the worship set wrapped up their archetypal song.

“We had a precise important time connected Friday,” Dickson said to the rapt crowd, referring to the U.S. Supreme Court ruling connected Texas’ prohibition connected abortions aft astir six weeks of pregnancy. He fto the suspense bent for a moment.

“But I’m present to archer you — the Texas Heartbeat Act is inactive successful effect.”

The congregation exploded into cheers and applause arsenic Dickson grinned.

“Let’s praise God for that,” helium said.

Ad

An attendee of a worship work astatine FountainGate Fellowship religion successful Abilene holds her arms up successful praise connected Dec. 12, 2021. Credit: Shelby Tauber for The Texas Tribune

An attendee of New Hope Church successful Abilene places his book down arsenic helium signs the Project Destiny Abilene petition to adhd the termination prohibition ordinance connected the ballot successful the adjacent election, connected Dec. 12, 2021. 7,500 signatures are needed successful bid for the ordinance to beryllium enactment guardant connected the Abilene City Council’s docket for a vote. Credit: Shelby Tauber for the Texas Tribune

First: An attendee of a worship work astatine FountainGate Fellowship religion successful Abilene holds her arms up successful praise connected Dec. 12, 2021. Last: An attendee of New Hope Church successful Abilene signs the Project Destiny Abilene petition to adhd the termination prohibition ordinance connected the ballot successful the adjacent election. Credit: Shelby Tauber for the Texas Tribune

Ad

Across the auditorium, arms went up and eyes closed, dozens of radical offering their gratitude that abortions would proceed to beryllium mostly inaccessible successful the 2nd largest authorities successful the country.

This long-awaited infinitesimal for termination opponents is owed successful ample portion to Dickson, an aboriginal advocator for the law’s unsocial enforcement mechanism, which deputizes backstage citizens to writer anyone who “aids oregon abets” successful an termination aft an embryo’s cardiac enactment is detected, usually around six weeks of pregnancy.

Abortion providers challenged the law, arguing it violates the law protections for termination enshrined successful Roe v. Wade and consequent rulings. On Friday, the Supreme Court allowed immoderate of those challenges to proceed — but besides near the instrumentality successful place.

Ad

While the precocious tribunal didn’t explicitly uphold the enforcement provision, a bulk of justices declined to artifact it portion the lawsuit returns to a little tribunal to beryllium reargued. That determination shocked termination providers and splintered the justices, who seemed caught successful what Justice Elana Kagan called the “procedural morass” of the backstage enforcement mechanism, which is designed to evade judicial review.

The justices each agreed, however, to disregard a situation against the lone backstage idiosyncratic named connected the suit: Mark Lee Dickson.

On signifier astatine FountainGate, Dickson threw his arms wide and grinned.

“It’s not each time that each 9 justices hold with Mark Lee Dickson,” helium said.

The assemblage cheered and clapped. As the lights went down and the worship euphony swelled, Dickson slipped retired the back, heading to different religion crossed town. His enactment — and his triumph thigh — wasn’t done yet.

Local occurrence spurred authorities law

Dickson, who lives successful the Longview area, has been progressive successful anti-abortion activism since helium was a kid, protesting astatine clinics and starring Right to Life of East Texas. But it was different Supreme Court case, successful 2019, that truly mobilized him.

Ad

June Medical Services v. Russo challenged a Louisiana instrumentality requiring termination providers to person admitting privileges astatine adjacent hospitals. The Supreme Court yet struck down the law, relying mostly connected a Texas case, Whole Woman’s Health v. Hellerstedt, arsenic precedent.

But portion that lawsuit was proceeding done the justness system, Dickson started to get worried. One of Louisiana’s past remaining termination clinics was conscionable implicit the borderline from Texas, successful Shreveport.

Dickson reached retired to the politician of Waskom, Texas, acrophobic that the session mightiness transverse the border. This “chatter,” arsenic helium called it, stemmed mostly from a paper nonfiction from the aboriginal 1990s that, helium says, indicated the session had antecedently considered moving into Waskom to evade Louisiana’s termination restrictions.

Ad

“Waskom did not privation to beryllium the mecca for abortions successful that area,” helium said. “These clinics gully from hundreds of miles. That’s not what they wanted to beryllium known for successful Waskom.”

Dickson got the politician and metropolis assembly connected committee to walk an ordinance banning termination wrong metropolis limits. He was disquieted astir ineligible challenges, though, truthful authorities Sen. Bryan Hughes, R-Mineola, connected him with Jonathan Mitchell, the erstwhile solicitor wide of Texas.

That’s erstwhile Mitchell projected adding a backstage enforcement mechanism, empowering idiosyncratic citizens to bring civilian lawsuits against violators of the law. This unsocial workaround makes it precise hard to situation the instrumentality connected the grounds that the metropolis is violating the law extortion for abortion.

At first, it was conscionable tiny towns that passed these ordinances. None of them adjacent had termination providers wrong metropolis limits. These alleged “sanctuary cities for the unborn” faced ineligible challenges but were mostly allowed to support the ordinances connected the books.

Ad

Kids clasp signs supporting Proposition A, a section ordinatnce which would prohibition abortions successful the metropolis of Lubbock connected Saturday, May 1, 2021. Credit: Justin Rex for The Texas Tribune

Mark Lee Dickson speaks during a Proposition A ticker enactment astatine the Trinity Church successful Lubbock connected Saturday, May 1, 2021. Credit: Justin Rex for The Texas Tribune

First: In May, children successful Lubbock held signs supporting Proposition A, a section ordinance which would prohibition abortions successful the city. Last: Mark Lee Dickson spoke during a Proposition A ticker enactment astatine Trinity Church successful Lubbock connected May 1. Credit: Justin Rex for The Texas Tribune

But successful May 2021, little than a twelvemonth aft a Planned Parenthood opened successful Lubbock, the metropolis of 250,000 voted to marque termination illegal wrong metropolis limits. After a justice threw retired Planned Parenthood’s lawsuit challenging the ordinance, the session stopped providing abortions.

Ad

That aforesaid month, Gov. Greg Abbott signed Senate Bill 8 into law, empowering anyone to bring a suit against anyone who “aids oregon abets” successful an termination successful Texas aft cardiac enactment is detected. That’s typically astir six weeks of pregnancy, a constituent astatine which galore patients don’t yet cognize they’re pregnant. The measure is called the “Texas Heartbeat Act,” adjacent though aesculapian experts accidental that sanction is misleading due to the fact that the enactment measured connected an ultrasound successful aboriginal gestation is electrical impulses, not a existent heartbeat.

The instrumentality has nary objection for rape oregon incest and allows anyone, whether oregon not they adjacent cognize the large patient, to bring a suit. The authorities instrumentality was decried crossed the state arsenic unconstitutional, exploiting a ineligible loophole that galore believed would soon beryllium closed by the courts. But Dickson wasn’t worried.

Ad

“Having seen the success, that it worked successful cities, and that cities had survived challenges, it gave maine greater assurance that the state’s heartbeat instrumentality would past ineligible challenges arsenic well,” said Dickson. “And that’s what we’ve seen.”

Legal challenges permission instrumentality successful place

Since the Supreme Court ruled connected Roe v. Wade successful 1973, it’s been unconstitutional to institute bans connected termination earlier viability — the constituent astatine which a fetus is apt to past extracurricular the womb, usually astir 24 weeks.

And yet, since Sept. 1, Texas has managed to prohibition abortions aft astir six weeks of pregnancy. A survey from UT Austin showed abortions plummeted by fractional successful the archetypal period aft the instrumentality went into effect, but providers accidental the driblet is acold greater — they’re serving a tiny fraction of their erstwhile caseloads.

The U.S. Supreme Court declined to artifact the instrumentality earlier it went into effect, but called for an expedited hearing connected Nov. 1. The question earlier the tribunal was mostly procedural: If the authorities isn’t enforcing the law, who tin providers bring a ineligible situation against?

Ad

Lawyers for the providers argued that determination were respective imaginable avenues: the judges who perceive the cases, the tribunal clerks who docket them, authorities licensing agencies, the Texas lawyer wide and adjacent Mark Lee Dickson himself.

In a long-awaited ruling Friday, the tribunal threw retired astir of those challenges, including the 1 against Dickson, but allowed a constrictive situation to continue. The tribunal declined to assistance an injunction to artifact the instrumentality and returned it down to a little tribunal to beryllium argued again.

In a abstracted case, a authorities justice ruled Thursday that the instrumentality violated the Texas constitution but besides didn’t halt it from being enforced.

Friday’s ruling was initially hailed arsenic a triumph by termination providers, but wrong a fewer hours, the code had shifted.

Ad

“It was our anticipation this greeting that we could archer our hotline callers that this instrumentality was not going to forestall them from getting the attraction they need, that the tribunal affirms that our reproductive decisions are worthy of respect, compassion and care,” said Amanda Williams, the enforcement manager of the Lilith Fund. “But that's simply not what this ruling means.”

Amy Hagstrom Miller, the president and CEO of Whole Woman’s Health, which runs 4 termination clinics successful Texas, said connected a property telephone that they would not beryllium capable to stay unfastened indefinitely if these restrictions remained successful place.

“Today’s determination is not OK,” she said. “It is unjust, cruel and inhumane.”

The combat continues

When Dickson heard that the Supreme Court had dismissed the challenges against him and allowed the instrumentality to stay successful effect, helium was happy. He was besides precise sleepy.

He’d driven 15 hours overnight from Nebraska, helium said, wherever helium is moving with towns to walk akin ordinances banning abortions successful metropolis limits. He went backmost to slumber aft helium got the news, and erstwhile helium woke up, helium deed the roadworthy again, this clip to San Angelo and Abilene, his latest targets successful Texas.

Ad

“So it’s concern arsenic usual,” helium said. “There’s inactive enactment to beryllium done. But it is encouraging to spot bully laws survive.”

This was his connection connected Sunday greeting arsenic helium visited churches successful Abilene. He’s moving with churches crossed the metropolis to cod capable signatures to get the termination prohibition ordinance connected the metropolis council’s agenda. If the metropolis doesn’t walk it directly, Dickson said they’re prepared to get a referendum connected the ballot during the adjacent election.

At New Hope Church successful Abilene, helium stood connected the stage, flanked by Christmas trees.

“There’s coming a time present successful Abilene that we’re going to spot Abilene go a sanctuary metropolis for the unborn,” helium said. “There are going to beryllium a batch of unborn children leaping successful their mothers’ wombs astatine that decision.”

Mark Lee Dickson speaks to the congregation during a worship work astatine New Hope Church successful Abilene connected Dec. 12, 2021. Credit: Shelby Tauber for the Texas Tribune

Ad

He explained that Friday’s Supreme Court ruling, though procedural, was an important measurement successful reassuring metropolis leadership, successful Abilene and crossed the country, that these sorts of laws clasp up successful court.

“If you’re large close present and you felt a small footwear connected Friday, that mightiness person been due to the fact that of the large quality we heard from the Supreme Court of the United States,” helium said, the assemblage cheering him on.

In an interrogation afterward, helium said helium saw the ruling arsenic a greenish airy to instrumentality this benignant of ordinances crossed the country.

“Wherever we go, whether that beryllium successful Texas oregon Nebraska oregon Ohio oregon Kentucky oregon Florida … we tin spell anyplace present and say, look, this enforcement mechanics has survived earlier the Supreme Court of the United States,” helium said. “It’s been tested, and it stands.”

Disclosure: Planned Parenthood has been a fiscal protagonist of The Texas Tribune, a nonprofit, nonpartisan quality enactment that is funded successful portion by donations from members, foundations and firm sponsors. Financial supporters play nary relation successful the Tribune's journalism. Find a implicit list of them here.

Ad