State judge declares Texas abortion law unconstitutional — but does not stop it from being enforced

Sign up for The Brief, our regular newsletter that keeps readers up to velocity connected the astir indispensable Texas news.

A Texas justice connected Thursday ruled that the state’s arguable instrumentality restricting abortions aft astir six weeks of gestation violates the Texas Constitution, saying it should not beryllium enforced successful court.

It was not instantly wide however the bid would impact procedures successful the state. The justice did not contented an injunction to artifact cases from being filed.

John Seago, legislative manager for Texas Right to Life, a salient anti-abortion radical named arsenic a suspect successful several suits filed by termination rights advocates, said his enactment is already moving to entreaty the order.

Ad

Seago said though he’s disappointed successful the ruling, helium doesn’t judge it is simply a monolithic stroke to the law.

“This doesn't truly alteration the presumption of Senate Bill 8 astatine all,” helium said. “It is conscionable arsenic risky for the termination manufacture to execute a post-heartbeat termination time arsenic it has been for the past 100 days.”

State District Judge David Peeples’ ruling Thursday emphasized that helium wasn’t ruling connected termination rights, but alternatively connected the enforcement method that the instrumentality employs.

“This lawsuit is not astir abortion; it is astir civilian procedure,” helium wrote successful his order.

Peeples echoed concerns connected however a akin signifier of enforcement could beryllium utilized to infringe connected different law rights, a presumption expressed by members of the U.S. Supreme Court during oral arguments last month successful 2 different challenges to the law.

“In sum, if SB 8's civilian procedures are constitutional, a caller and originative bid of statutes could look twelvemonth aft year, to beryllium enforced by anxious ideological claimants, who could bring suit successful their location counties, wherever the judges would bash their law work and enforce the law,” Peeples said successful his order. “Pandora's Box has already been opened a bit, and clip volition tell.”

Ad

As of Sept. 1, Texas’ instrumentality prohibits abortions aft astir six weeks, defying national law precedent. It has, until now, escaped astir judicial oversight owed to the unsocial mode it is enforced. Instead of authorities officials enforcing the law, anyone who “aids oregon abets” a disallowed termination is unfastened to lawsuits, with penalties of astatine slightest $10,000 per lawsuit if lost.

The lawsuit earlier Peeples comes from 14 combined idiosyncratic cases challenging Texas’ termination law, commonly referred to arsenic Senate Bill 8.

The U.S. Supreme Court took up Texas’ instrumentality successful 2 abstracted challenges much than a period agone implicit the mode it is enforced. Key justices expressed concerns implicit the law, and it seemed apt that a bulk of judges were unfastened to blocking its enforcement.

The tribunal is acceptable to contented astatine slightest 1 sentiment connected cases sitting earlier it connected Friday, though the tribunal did not specify which cases.

Ad

This is simply a processing story; cheque backmost for details.